1300 28 29 63 Make An Enquiry

Play and Creativity: You Can’t Schedule a Good Idea

Most of us have sat through a particular kind of meeting. It appears in the calendar as an ideas workshop, booked for an hour on a Thursday afternoon between a budget review and a client call. Someone asks for blue-sky thinking, and the room goes quiet in a way that has nothing to do with intelligence. A safe idea is offered, a few others build on it carefully, and the hour ends with a whiteboard that looks a lot like last year's.

It is tempting to read that silence as a talent problem. Yet the same people often solve a stubborn problem on the drive home or find their best thinking in the shower. The capacity is there. What changes is the condition they are being asked to use it in. This is where the relationship between play and creativity becomes more than a pleasant idea, because you can schedule a meeting about ideas, but you cannot schedule a good idea.

The Gap Between Asking and Allowing

Very few leaders would say creativity doesn't matter. In a 2010 McKinsey global survey of more than 2,000 executives, 84 per cent said innovation was extremely or very important to their company's growth strategy. Yet McKinsey's own innovation leaders have since noted that only 6 per cent of executives are satisfied with their innovation performance, a figure they say has barely moved in almost a decade. They also point to a number that deserves more attention: more than 85 per cent of innovation practitioners report that fear often or always holds innovation back.

That gap is usually treated as a process problem, and process does matter. But the fear figure points somewhere more human. Ideas arrive half-formed, slightly wrong and easy to dismiss, and sharing one means accepting a small social risk. When that risk feels high, most people make a reasonable choice. They wait until the thought is polished, or they keep it to themselves.

Time pressure tells a similar story. When Harvard Business School researchers led by Teresa Amabile analysed more than 9,000 daily diary entries from 177 employees working on creative projects, they found that the more time pressure people felt on a given day, the less likely they were to think creatively. On the days people rated their pressure at its highest, they were 45 per cent less likely to think creatively, and the effect lingered for a couple of days afterwards. Participants believed they were more creative under pressure. Their diaries showed the opposite. The researchers described the worst of these days as a treadmill, with people pulled in too many directions to stay with any one problem.

None of this makes deadlines the enemy. The same research found pressure could coexist with creativity when people were protected from distraction and understood why the work mattered. The point is that creativity responds to its conditions, and many workplaces have quietly arranged those conditions against it. Constant interruption, evaluation and visibility, taken together, make a guarded mind the sensible default. Those conditions also cover a large share of adult life. Paid work fills much of the week for most of us, as the AIHW's indicators on work show, and much of it is spent sitting still, the kind of time Australia's physical activity and sedentary behaviour guidelines suggest breaking up as often as we can.

Creativity Is a State Before It Is a Skill

A state is the condition a person is in at a given moment, before they say or do anything. It includes how guarded they feel, how much attention they have spare, and how safe it seems to be wrong. The same person, with the same skills, can be inventive on a Tuesday and stuck on a Wednesday.

When someone feels rushed, judged or socially exposed, attention tends to tilt towards self-protection. That is not a flaw. It is an old and useful response that keeps us careful. But self-protection and exploration pull in different directions. Exploration needs room to follow a thought that might go nowhere and to say something that sounds odd before it sounds clever. Self-protection narrows attention towards what is known and approved. People in that state still work hard. They just reach for the familiar.

Watch children with a box of odds and ends and you can see the other state at work. In a University of Canberra study of loose parts play in a primary school classroom, Year 4 children and their teachers reported more creativity after eight weeks of open-ended play, with more imaginative play in one group and a greater number of ideas in the other. That kind of time isn't guaranteed even in childhood, with the ABS reporting that more children are spending 20 hours or more a week on screens and fewer are taking part in creative activities outside school.

This is why creativity techniques on their own can disappoint. Frameworks and prompts are genuinely useful, and they are a big part of building creativity into a company. But a technique used from a guarded state tends to produce guarded ideas. If we want different thinking, we have to pay attention to the state people are thinking from.

Play and Creativity: What a State of Play Makes Possible

The National Institute for Play describes play as both a state and a trait. The trait is playfulness, a person's broader disposition towards curiosity, lightness and seeing problems as interesting challenges. The state is the experience of playing itself: absorbed, curious, a little outside ordinary time, and engaged for its own sake rather than for a result. Everyone starts from a different baseline, but anyone can enter the state, and time spent there can help strengthen the trait. Most adults never really stopped playing, either. The Australia Plays 2025 research found that 84 per cent of working-age Australians play video games, and the average player is now 35. The play is still there. It just rarely makes it through the office door.

What matters most for creativity is what a state of play does to the stakes. In play, a wrong move is part of the game and trying something unusual costs very little, so the steady self-monitoring that accompanies most professional conversations can begin to quieten. Play also engages the brain's reward and social systems, sometimes described as a DOSE of play: dopamine, oxytocin, serotonin and endorphins, chemistry associated with motivation, connection, steadier mood and ease. In that state, people can become more willing to explore, more comfortable with ambiguity and more generous with one another's unfinished ideas.

Research on mood and thinking points in a similar direction. In a series of experiments, psychologist Alice Isen and her colleagues found that people who had watched a few minutes of comedy or received a small bag of lollies were more likely to solve problems that require creative ingenuity than people in neutral or negative conditions. These were short laboratory tasks, and a good mood is not the same thing as play, but the finding fits a broader pattern: when people feel positive and unthreatened, their thinking can become more flexible.

There is evidence from real workplaces too. In a Swedish study published in the American Journal of Play, researchers placed simple play cues, such as playful props and colourful sweets, on the table halfway through real workplace meetings. Groups that received them reported a significantly more creative climate and more playfulness, with no loss in how productive the meeting felt. The effect was small, and one study in one setting doesn't prove that play causes better ideas. It is still a useful reminder that the conditions around a conversation shape the thinking that happens inside it.

Play Isn't a Break From the Serious Work

It is easy to hear all of this as an argument for beanbags and a games room. It isn't. A veneer of fun laid over the same pressures changes very little. The question is not whether work looks playful, but whether people have regular access to a state in which exploring feels safe.

In practice, that can be quite ordinary. It might mean opening a problem-solving session with a low-stakes challenge where everyone gets something wrong together before the real question is on the table. It might mean asking for the worst possible solution first, so nobody has to be right straight away. It might mean leaders sharing their own half-formed thinking, which signals that unfinished ideas are welcome. Away from the desk, it might be a few unhurried work retreat activities, a scavenger hunt with QR codes or a round of creative problem-solving games. The format matters less than whether people feel free to get things wrong.

For teams, shared play adds something else. When colleagues have built something together, watched it fail and tried again, the social cost of the next unusual idea can drop. They have already seen one another be imperfect, and nothing bad happened. That familiarity is hard to create in a workshop about trust, yet it can grow naturally through playing together, which is the thinking behind our creative team building programs.

Seen this way, play is not a pause from serious work. It is part of the conditions creative work depends on.

So, Can You Schedule a Good Idea?

Not quite. You can schedule the time, and protecting it is worth doing. But the idea itself comes from a state, and states respond to conditions rather than instructions. No calendar invite can make someone feel safe enough to say the strange thing that turns out to matter.

That shifts the useful question for leaders. It is less about finding more creative people and more about what our people are protecting themselves from, and what would let them need that protection less. The answer rarely lives in a single initiative. It lives in small, repeated choices about pace, permission and how an unfinished idea is received the first time someone shares it.

A good place to begin is noticing. Where do ideas actually surface in your team, and where do they go quiet? What happened the last time someone offered something half-formed?

If you would like a structured way to explore those questions, our free Culture Playbook is a reflection tool for looking at the conditions and everyday choices that shape how your team works and thinks together. And if you are curious about the science underneath, you can read more about the power of play at work.

Who We Are

Corporate Challenge Events is a play-based team building company helping leaders build positive team cultures through serious fun with lasting impact.

For more than 30 years, we have helped teams across Australia and New Zealand make play practical, purposeful and deeply human. Through our exclusive Australasian partnership with the National Institute for Play, we translate the science of play into programs and experiences that help people connect, adapt and create together.

We believe play is not a break from serious work. It is part of what makes serious work possible.